This page shows before and after photos for Worthington historic buildings. Only those buildings constructed prior to 1930 are included. They are listed alphabetically by street name and numerically by address. Click on any photo for a larger image.
**Last Updated: 3/9/2024- Added to High Street.
Existing Historic Buildings
Dublin-Granville Road
1. Residential House: 44 W. Dublin-Granville Road: 1924
Photo taken in 1957.
Photo taken in 2018.
2. Llewellyn McKitrick House: 63 W. Dublin-Granville Road: Around 1900
Photo taken in 1962.
Photo taken in 2016.
3. Residential House: 64 W. Dublin-Granville Road: 1837
Photo taken in 1956.
Photo taken in 2012.
4. Lillian Gardner House: 80 W. Dublin-Granville Road: 1890
Photo taken in 1958.
Photo taken in 2015.
5. Robert Thompson House: 126 W. Dublin-Granville Road: 1920
Photo taken in 1960.
Photo taken in 2017.
6. Harry Buzzaird House: 151 E. Dublin-Granville Road: 1880
Photo taken in 1958.
Photo taken in 2015.
7. Ida Buzzaird House: 159-161 E. Dublin-Granville Road: 1921
Photo taken in 1964.
Photo taken in 2017.
8. Scott Hester House: 195 E. Dublin-Granville Road: 1875
Photo taken in 1959.
Photo taken in 2018.
9. Chester Hard House: 215 E. Dublin-Granville Road: 1853
Photo taken in 1961.
Photo taken in 2017.
10. William Payne House: 348 E. Dublin-Granville Road: 1924
Photo taken in 1958.
Photo taken in 2018.
Hartford Street
1. James Kinney House: 577 Hartford Street: Around 1910
Photo taken in 1965.
Photo taken in 2017.
2. Honora Hannon House: 580 Hartford Street: 1856
Photo taken in 1962.
Photo taken in 2017.
3. Oral South House: 620 Hartford Street: Around 1910
Photo taken in 1957.
Photo taken in 2017.
4. Rosella Willie House: 655 Hartford Street: 1860
Photo taken in 1965.
Photo taken in 2017.
5. Carl Marks House: 680 Hartford Street: Around 1900
Photo taken in 1957.
Photo taken in 2014.
High Street
1. Worthington Methodist Episcopal Church: 600 N. High Street: 1926
Photo taken in 1926.
Photo taken in 2021.
2. New England Masonic Lodge: 634 N. High Street: 1820
Photo taken around 1900.
Photo taken in 2018.
3. Worthington Inn: 649 N. High Street: 1831
Photo taken in 1905.
Photo taken in 2019.
4. Home Market and Lady Alice Beauty Salon buildings: 660-666 N. High Street: Around 1910
Photo taken in 1945.
Photo taken in 2021.
5. St. Johns Episcopal Church: 700 N. High Street: 1831
Photo taken around 1955.
Photo taken in 2019.
6. Demas Adams House: 721 N. High Street: 1820
Photo taken in 1975.
Photo taken in 2019.
7. Orange Johnson House: 956 N. High Street: 1816
Photo taken in 1972.
Photo taken in 2020.
8. Mark Russell House: 5807 N. High Street: 1850: Unfortunately, the house is almost completely invisible now do to tree growth.
Photo taken in 1930.
Photo taken in 2020.
Morning Street
1. Martha Beaver House: 611 Morning Street: 1893
Photo taken in 1961
Photo taken in 2017.
2. Ora Thompson House: 612 Morning Street: 1928
Photo taken in 1963.
Photo taken in 2017.
3. Marcella Tarbutton House: 618 Morning Street: 1928
Photo taken in 1962.
Photo taken in 2017.
4. Maude Parmer House: 626 Morning Street: 1928
Photo taken in 1957.
Photo taken in 2017.
5. Lillian Tuller House: 656 Morning Street: 1875
Photo taken in 1960.
Photo taken in 2017.
6. James Barker House: 680 Morning Street: 1875
Photo taken in 1964.
Photo taken in 2017.
7. Christina Thomas House: 771 Morning Street: 1909
Photo taken in 1960.
Photo taken in 2017.
8. Katherine Porter House: 777-779 Morning Street: 1917
Photo taken in 1962.
Photo taken in 2015.
New England Avenue
1. John Snow House: 41 W. New England Avenue: 1816
Photo taken around 1930.
Photo taken in 2017.
North Street
1. Caleb Ladd House: 72 E. North Street: 1820: This house was part of the Underground Railroad.
Photo taken in 1975.
Photo taken in 2019.
Short Street
1. Residential House: 40 W. Short Street: Around 1900
Photo taken in 1960.
Photo taken in 2017.
Demolished Historic Buildings
Dublin-Granville Road
1. Residential House: 2171 W. Dublin-Granville Road: 1928-1963: Demolished to build part of the strip retail center that still exists today.
Photo taken in 1958.
Photo taken in 2022.
2. Residential House: 2273 W. Dublin-Granville Road: Around 1920-Around 1965: Demolished for new development. Today, the site is part of a retail strip center.
Photo taken in 1961.
Photo taken in 2022.
High Street
1. Park Hotel: 582 N. High Street: 1839-1962: Demolished for church parking.
Photo taken in 1915.
Photo taken in 2019.
2. Ault Hardware: 680 N. High Street: Around 1900-1962: Demolished for unknown reasons, but likely to build the current building.
Photo taken in 1945.
Photo taken in 2022.
3. Griswold Inn & Tavern: 778 N. High Street: 1811-1964: Demolished to build a Huntington National Bank branch. Today the site is home to the Griswold Center.
Photo taken in 1963.
Photo taken in 2018.
Proprietors Road
1. Residential House: 789 Proprietors Road: Around 1890-Around 1985: Unknown reasons for demolition. The site was vacant until the current apartment complex was built in 2007.
Photo taken in 1955.
Photo taken in 2017.
