Bexley Historic Buildings




Bexley historic buildings

This page highlights before and after photos of Bexley historic buildings built before 1930. Click on any image for a larger view.

**Last Updated: 10/20/2023- Replaced all 2015 and earlier After photos with newer versions, and added new photos for Cassady Avenue.

Existing Historic Buildings

Bexford Place
1. Ruth Odell House: 2461 Bexford Place: 1923

Photo taken in 1970.

Photo taken in 2017.

2. Marie Lowenstein House: 2469 Bexford Place: 1923

Photo taken in 1964.

Photo taken in 2017.

3. Loyd Mayer House: 2473 Bexford Place: 1923

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2021.

4. Daniel Richards House: 2490 Bexford Place: 1923

Photo taken in 1961.

Photo taken in 2021.

5. Thomas Carr House: 2495 Bexford Place: 1923

Photo taken in 1961.

Photo taken in 2021.

6. Oliver Steward House: 2501 Bexford Place: 1923

Photo taken in 1962.

Photo taken in 2021.

7. Herbert Young House: 2504 Bexford Place: 1925

Photo taken in 1967.

Photo taken in 2021.

8. Robert Hayes House: 2505 Bexford Place: 1928

Photo taken in 1966.

Photo taken in 2021.

9. Ethel Wendt House: 2508 Bexford Place: 1924

Photo taken in 1964.

Photo taken in 2017.

Brentwood Road
1. Jeannette Herbst House: 2345 Brentwood Road: 1925

Bexley historic buildings 2345 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1956.

2345 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

2. Anna Reiss House: 2350 Brentwood Road: 1922

Bexley historic buildings 2350 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1969.

2350 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

3. Henry Lorenz House: 2355 Brentwood Road: 1924

Bexley historic buildings 2355 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1972.

2355 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

4. Frank Christ House: 2364 Brentwood Road: 1921

Bexley historic buildings 2364 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1970.

2364 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

5. Clara Blesch House: 2370 Brentwood Road: 1923

Bexley historic buildings 2370 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1966.

2370 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

6. Edward Holz House: 2373 Brentwood Road: 1927

Bexley historic buildings 2373 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1974.

2373 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

7. John Holzemer House: 2409 Brentwood Road: 1926

Bexley historic buildings 2409 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1964.

2409 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2017.

8. L. Brooks House: 2412 Brentwood Road: 1923

Bexley historic buildings 2412 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1961.

2412 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2017.

9. Stanley Samson House: 2416 Brentwood Road: 1915

Bexley historic buildings 2416 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1961.

2416 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

10. Lou Wallick House: 2424 Brentwood Road: 1923

Bexley historic buildings 2424 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1962.

2424 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

11. Jacob Mattlin House: 2425 Brentwood Road: 1924

Bexley historic buildings 2425 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1963.

2425 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

12. Susan Miller House: 2451 Brentwood Road: 1917

Bexley historic buildings 2451 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1956.

2451 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

13. Mary Auld House: 2498 Brentwood Road: 1924

Bexley historic buildings 2498 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1956.

2498 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

14. Dorothy Carroll House: 2523 Brentwood Road: 1923

Bexley historic buildings 2523 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1955.

2523 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

15. Marian Hunt House: 2534 Brentwood Road: 1920

Bexley historic buildings 2534 Brentwood Road

Photo taken in 1965.

2534 Brentwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

Bryden Road
1. Catherine Lawler House: 2173 Bryden Road: 1913

Photo taken in 1961.

Photo taken in 2019.

2. Adele Joseph House: 2180 Bryden Road: 1920

Photo taken in 1975.

Photo taken in 2021.

3. Gladys Zeigler House: 2188 Bryden Road: 1920

Photo taken in 1959.

Photo taken in 2019.

4. Darron Wrinkle House: 2202 Bryden Road: 1919

Photo taken in 1957.

2202 Bryden Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2021.

5. Kate Martin House: 2206 Bryden Road: 1920

Photo taken in 1972.

Photo taken in 2019.

6. John Dunham House: 2240 Bryden Road: 1922

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2019.

7. Carl Brooke House: 2250 Bryden Road: 1915

Photo taken in 1959.

Photo taken in 2019.

8. Harry Moore House: 2258 Bryden Road: 1920

Photo taken in 1957.

2258 Bryden Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

9. Louis Levin House: 2265 Bryden Road: 1925

Photo taken in 1964.

Photo taken in 2019.

10. Albert Van Hise House: 2341 Bryden Road: 1923

Photo taken in 1961.

Photo taken in 2017.

11. Clifford Dingledine House: 2345 Bryden Road: 1919

Photo taken in 1974.

Photo taken in 2017.

12. Margaret McGhee House: 2355 Bryden Road: 1923

Photo taken in 1967.

Photo taken in 2019.

13. Fred Schenk House: 2361 Bryden Road: 1918

Photo taken in 1961.

Photo taken in 2019.

14. Frederick Eckley House: 2364 Bryden Road: 1920

Photo taken in 1954.

Photo taken in 2019.

15. Henry Schleppi House: 2368 Bryden Road: 1918

Photo taken in 1956.

2368 Bryden Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

16. Chester Rose House: 2371 Bryden Road: 1923

Photo taken in 1973.

Photo taken in 2019.

17. Herman Engler House: 2400 Bryden Road: 1918

Photo taken in 1958.

Photo taken in 2019.

18. Beatrice Ludwig House: 2401 Bryden Road: 1915

Photo taken in 1968.

Photo taken in 2017.

19. Ira Morris House: 2403 Bryden Road: 1922

Photo taken in 1955.

Photo taken in 2019.

20. Donald Hamilton House: 2455 Bryden Road: 1924

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2019.

21. Daisy Anderson House: 2461 Bryden Road: 1922

Photo taken in 1958.

Photo taken in 2019.

22. John King House: 2478 Bryden Road: 1918

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2019.

23. Jeannette Isaac House: 2495 Bryden Road: 1921

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2017.

24. Robert Dienst House: 2500 Bryden Road: 1923

Photo taken in 1960.

2500 Bryden Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

25. Mary Lee House: 2503 Bryden Road: 1921

Photo taken in 1975.

2503 Bryden Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

26. Clarence Lauffer House: 2549 Bryden Road: 1922

Photo taken in 1970.

2549 Bryden Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

27. Arthur Dunn House: 2550 Bryden Road: 1917

Photo taken in 1955.

Photo taken in 2017.

28. Mollie Handley House: 2561 Bryden Road: 1922

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2017.

29. Stella Houstle House: 2584 Bryden Road: 1925

Photo taken in 1968.

2584 Bryden Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

30. Ruth Carlile House: 2595 Bryden Road: 1922

Photo taken in 1960.

2595 Bryden Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2021.

31. German Heurich House: 2596 Bryden Road: 1920

Photo taken in 1956.

2596 Bryden Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

32. Kenneth Browne House: 2605 Bryden Road: 1928

Photo taken in 1968.

Photo taken in 2019.

Cassady Avenue
1. Stephen Hanna House: 23 S. Cassady Avenue: 1928

Photo taken in 1973.

Photo taken in 2016.

2. Dorothy Schafer House: 37 S. Cassady Avenue: 1928

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2017.

3. Lola Quigley House: 43 S. Cassady Avenue: 1928

Photo taken in 1964.

Photo taken in 2016.

4. Sarah Newlove House: 49 S. Cassady Avenue: 1928

Photo taken in 1961.

Photo taken in 2017.

5. Winifred Jaycox House: 58 S. Cassady Avenue: 1923

Photo taken in 1966.

Photo taken in 2017.

6. Eleanor Nonemacher House: 64 N. Cassady Avenue: 1925

Photo taken in 1955.

Photo taken in 2017.

7. Clara Martin House: 71 S. Cassady Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1960.

Photo taken in 2017.

8. John Merritt House: 76 N. Cassady Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2019.

9. Marcellus Kerstetter House: 77 S. Cassady Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1958.

Photo taken in 2019.

10. Lily Thomas House: 85 S. Cassady Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1960.

Photo taken in 2019.

11. Burton Nafzger House: 91 S. Cassady Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1962.

Photo taken in 2016.

12. Karl Kaiser House: 103 S. Cassady Avenue: 1924

Photo taken in 1966.


Photo taken in 2019.


13. Mary Olds House: 108 N. Cassady Avenue: 1923
Bexley historic buildings 108 N. Cassady Avenue

Photo taken in 1965.


108 N. Cassady Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.


14. John Powell House: 123 S. Cassady Avenue: 1926
Bexley historic buildings 123 S. Cassady Avenue

Photo taken in 1965.


123 S. Cassady Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.


15. Gertrude McLaughlin House: 124 S. Cassady Avenue: 1924
Bexley historic buildings 124 S. Cassady Avenue

Photo taken in 1964.


124 S. Cassady Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.


16. Bertha Devore House: 130 S. Cassady Avenue: 1923
Bexley historic buildings 130 S. Cassady Avenue

Photo taken in 1971.


130 S. Cassady Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.


17. Stella Landen House: 141 S. Cassady Avenue: 1925
Bexley historic buildings 141 S. Cassady Avenue

Photo taken in 1962.


141 S. Cassady Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.


18. Nellie Brown House: 154 N. Cassady Avenue: 1928
Bexley historic buildings 154 N. Cassady Avenue

Photo taken in 1966.


154 N. Cassady Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.


19. Daniel Sanor House: 170 S. Cassady Avenue: 1926

Chelsea Avenue
1. Cecil Bryant House: 712 Chelsea Avenue: 1929

Photo taken in 1974.

Photo taken in 2017.

2. Residential House: 727 Chelsea Avenue: 1923

Photo taken in 1966.

Photo taken in 2017.

3. Enoch Heston House: 750 Chelsea Avenue: 1923

Photo taken in 1971.

Photo taken in 2016.

4. Fred Kinser House: 828 Chelsea Avenue: 1928

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2017.

5. William Darby House: 911 Chelsea Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1975.

Photo taken in 2016.

6. Francis Thompson House: 964 Chelsea Avenue: 1928

Photo taken in 1968.

Photo taken in 2017.

7. Norma Smith House: 965 Chelsea Avenue: 1928

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2016.

Columbia Avenue
1. Robert Wheaton House: 63 N. Columbia Avenue: Around 1918

Photo taken in 1971.

Photo taken in 2019.

2. Florence Harrison House: 107 N. Columbia Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2019.

3. Helen Archer House: 140 S. Columbia Avenue: 1918

Photo taken in 1958.

Photo taken in 2017.

4. Isabella Ross House: 167 S. Columbia Avenue: 1923

Photo taken in 1966.

Bexley historic buildings 167 S. Columbia Avenue

Photo taken in 2022.

5. Helen Hoster House: 200 N. Columbia Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2017.

6. Ada Dienst House: 209 S. Columbia Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1961.

Photo taken in 2016.

7. Dorothy Glenn House: 275 S. Columbia Avenue: 1919

Photo taken in 1962.

Photo taken in 2017.

8. Vivian McCune House: 296 N. Columbia Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1957.

Photo taken in 2017.

9. Lee Boda House: 351 S. Columbia Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1972.

Photo taken in 2019.

10. Helen Buckmaster House: 373 S. Columbia Avenue: 1914

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2017.

11. Julia Glick House: 381 S. Columbia Avenue: 1923

Photo taken in 1966.

Photo taken in 2017.

12. Dora Flory House: 399 S. Columbia Avenue: 1923

Photo taken in 1967.

Photo taken in 2017.

13. Ralph Fallon House: 403 N. Columbia Avenue: 1929

Photo taken in 1957.

Photo taken in 2017.

14. James Stocker House: 410 S. Columbia Avenue: 1919

Photo taken in 1956.

Photo taken in 2019.

15. Vola Sherman House: 419 S. Columbia Avenue: 1918

Photo taken in 1971.

Photo taken in 2017.

16. John Bauermeister House: 435 S. Columbia Avenue: 1929

Photo taken in 1959.

Photo taken in 2017.

17. Jacob Yeakle House: 436 S. Columbia Avenue: 1919

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2017.

18. Alice Beggs House: 446 S. Columbia Avenue: 1922

Photo taken in 1969.

Photo taken in 2017.

Columbus Avenue
1. John Hoffman House: 2687 Columbus Avenue: Around 1900

Photo taken in 1956.

Photo taken in 2017.

2. Peter Schwartz House: 2829 Columbus Avenue: 1906

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2017.

3. Isadore Frey House: 2830 Columbus Avenue: 1924

Photo taken in 1972.

2830 Columbus Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

Dale Avenue
1. Hugh Archer House: 2435 Dale Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1969.

Photo taken in 2019.

2. Warren Stevens House: 2442 Dale Avenue: 1929

Photo taken in 1964.

Photo taken in 2019.

3. Josephine Fulton House: 2449 Dale Avenue: 1923

Photo taken in 1970.

Photo taken in 2019.

4. Frank Kaufman House: 2450 Dale Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1967.

Photo taken in 2019.

5.Anna McKinnon House: 2455 Dale Avenue: 1923

Photo taken in 1962.

Photo taken in 2019.

6. William Wheaton House: 2463 Dale Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1957.

Photo taken in 2019.

7. John Girard House: 2464 Dale Avenue: 1929

Photo taken in 1957.

Photo taken in 2019.

8. Stanley Kerr House: 3124 Dale Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1964.

Photo taken in 2019.

Dawson Avenue
1. Clara Palmer House: 35 S. Dawson Avenue: 1922

Photo taken in 1966.

Photo taken in 2019.

2. Laura Keller House: 36 S. Dawson Avenue: 1924

Photo taken in 1970.

Photo taken in 2019.

3. Myrle Blair House: 50 S. Dawson Avenue: 1924

Photo taken in 1969.

Photo taken in 2019.

4. Harold Marsh House: 62 S. Dawson Avenue: 1924

Photo taken in 1956.

Photo taken in 2019.

5. Katharine Sharp House: 76 S. Dawson Avenue: 1924

Photo taken in 1964.

Photo taken in 2019.



Main Street
1. Laura Courtright House: 2369 E. Main Street: 1923

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2017.

2. Dora Kinsell House: 2469 E. Main Street: 1923

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2017.

Northview Avenue
1. Walter Chrysler House: 685 Northview Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1972.

Photo taken in 2017.

2. Residential House: 707 Northview Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2017.

3. Charles Shields House: 713 Northview Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1974.

Photo taken in 2017.

4. Frank Wengert House: 772 Northview Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1956.

772 Northview Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

5. Residential House: 777 Northview Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1965.

777 Northview Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

Parkview Avenue
1. Christina Kendall House: 86 S. Parkview Avenue: 1918

Photo taken in 1919.

Photo taken in 2017.

Pleasant Ridge Avenue
1. Carl Vogel House: 845 Pleasant Ridge Avenue: 1925

Bexley historic buildings 845 Pleasant Ridge Avenue

Photo taken in 1962.

845 Pleasant Ridge Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

Preston Road
1. Laura Culver House: 68 Preston Road: 1928

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2016.

2. Edward Lerch House: 159 Preston Road: 1913

Photo taken in 1918.

Photo taken in 2019.

3. Edward Jones House: 162 Preston Road: 1927

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2016.

4. Grace Johnson House: 227 Preston Road: 1920

Photo taken in 1959.

Photo taken in 2017.

Sheridan Avenue
1. William Schlitt House: 727 Sheridan Avenue: 1925

Photo taken in 1967.

Photo taken in 2017.

2. Louis Montei House: 746-748 Sheridan Avenue: 1926

Photo taken in 1926.

Photo taken in 2017.

3. John Miller House: 861 Sheridan Avenue: 1924

Photo taken in 1965.

861 Sheridan Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

4. Rile Beery House: 870-872 Sheridan Avenue: 1928

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2017.

5. Mamie DeVault House: 911 Sheridan Avenue: 1919

Photo taken in 1964.

911 Sheridan Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2021.

6. Nannie Ikehorn House: 951 Sheridan Avenue: 1922

Photo taken in 1963.

Photo taken in 2017.

Stanbery Avenue
1. William Eidson House: 145 Stanbery Avenue: 1929

Photo taken in 1940.

Photo taken in 2017.

2. Louise Cox House: 148 Stanbery Avenue: 1924

Bexley historic buildings 148 Stanbery Avenue

Photo taken in 1975.

148 Stanbery Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

3. Adolph Waller House: 210 Stanbery Avenue: 1923

Bexley historic buildings 210 Stanbery Avenue

Photo taken in 1975.

210 Stanbery Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2021.

Stanwood Road
1. Elizabeth Kern House: 108 N. Stanwood Road: 1929

Bexley historic buildings 108 N. Stanwood Road

Photo taken in 1975.

108 N. Stanwood Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2021.

Vernon Road
1. Mollie Koch House: 765 Vernon Road: 1925

Bexley historic buildings 765 Vernon Road

Photo taken in 1974.

765 Vernon Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2019.

2. Fred Hamilton House: 798 Vernon Road: 1929

Bexley historic buildings 798 Vernon Road

Photo taken in 1975.

798 Vernon Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2021.

3. Karl Rodebaugh House: 832 Vernon Road: 1928

Bexley historic buildings 832 Vernon Road

Photo taken in 1974.

832 Vernon Road Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2021.

Westland Avenue
1. Dessa Paddock House: 320 Westland Avenue: 1927

Photo taken in 1970.

Photo taken in 2017.

Demolished Historic Buildings

Broad Street
1. Charles E. Markeson House: 2086 E. Broad Street, Bexley: Around 1885-Before 1923: Unknown reason for demolition. A newer home went on the site in 1927, but this house is not on the records as existing as early as 1923, so it’s unknown exactly when it was torn down. The Markeson house was set back away from Broad significantly further than the current house is.

Photo taken in 1889.

Photo taken in 2017.

Bryden Road
1. Residential House: 2215 Bryden Road: Around 1910-1980: Demolished to build new homes on the site.

Photo taken in 1956.

Photo taken in 2019.

Cassady Avenue
1. Fannie Stimmel House: 104 N. Cassady Avenue: 1923-1991: Demolished for unknown reasons, but the lot has remained vacant.

Bexley historic buildings 104 N. Cassady Avenue

Photo taken in 1967.


104 N. Cassady Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2016.

Columbia Avenue
1. Claude Meeker House: 256 S. Columbia Avenue: Around 1890-1920: A new home, which still exists, replaced it.

Photo taken in 1912.


256 S. Columbia Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2021.

2. Halbert Blakey House: 301 N. Columbia Avenue: 1926-2002: Demolished to build the current house, which was completed in 2003.

Photo taken in 1965.

Photo taken in 2017.

3. Andrew Burns House: 424 S. Columbia Avenue: 1922-2018: Demolished to build a new house on the site.

Photo taken in 1962.

Photo taken in 2019.

Dawson Avenue
1. Elizabeth Strickler House: 69 S. Dawson Avenue: 1924-1994: Demolished to build the current house on the site.

Photo taken in 1970.

Photo taken in 2017.

Main Street
1. Margery Thomas House: 2552 E. Main Street: 1926-1970: Demolished for a business parking lot that still exists.

Photo taken in 1969.

Photo taken in 2019.

2. Frank Gould House: 2599 E. Main Street: 1925-2010: Demolished for a business parking lot that still exists.

Photo taken in 1962.

Photo taken in 2019.

Pleasant Ridge Avenue
1. Oma Allen House: 696 Pleasant Ridge Avenue: Around 1915-1989: The site was purchased by Capital University in 1959. The university eventually demolished the house, along with several others, to create a parking lot that still exists today.

Bexley historic buildings 696 Pleasant Ridge Avenue

Photo taken in 1959.

696 Pleasant Ridge Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

2. Sam Mangia House: 706 Pleasant Ridge Avenue: Around 1915-1989: Purchased by Capital University in 1963, it was torn down for a parking lot that still exists today.

Bexley historic buildings 706 Pleasant Ridge Avenue

Photo taken in 1956.

706 Pleasant Ridge Avenue Bexley, Ohio

Photo taken in 2022.

3. Residential House: 796 Pleasant Ridge Avenue: Around 1915-1989: As with the other homes on this block, the house was demolished for a Capital University parking lot.

Bexley historic buildings 796 Pleasant Ridge Avenue

Photo taken in 1963.

796 Pleasant Ridge Avenue Bexley, Ohiio

Photo taken in 2022.

The Historic Building Database looks at historic buildings in many additional Columbus neighborhoods and suburbs.